← The theme library

Wine & Tasting

Old World vs New World

A comparative pour disguised as a party. Each guest brings two bottles of the same grape — one European, one not — and the table tastes them head to head, blind. Vote for the wine you’d actually buy. The wine-nerd entry point.

Anyone Medium group Any season Medium effort
Wine educationDeepen friendships
PurposePut two wine philosophies — restraint and earth vs fruit and power — side by side and let the table decide which worl…
VoteWhich wine you’d actually buy again — blind, before the labels surface.
RevealUnbag in pairs: Old World first, New World second, then flip the bottles and let the room see what it preferred.
Run of show

What it's for

Put two wine philosophies — restraint and earth vs fruit and power — side by side and let the table decide which world it lives in.

The guest's job

Bring two bottles of the same grape: one European, one not, both bagged and numbered before you arrive.

The vote

Which wine you’d actually buy again — blind, before the labels surface.

The reveal

Unbag in pairs: Old World first, New World second, then flip the bottles and let the room see what it preferred.

Food & drink spine

One clean protein — roast chicken, a simple pasta — that doesn’t compete with the wines.

Conversation fuel

"Does terroir actually taste like anything, or is it a story we’ve agreed to believe?"

How it flops — steer around it

Bottles not bagged on arrival. The whole premise collapses if anyone sees a label early.

A bespoke dinner-party concierge. Vote with conviction; bring something defensible. Themes · Playbook